West Allis Cheese and Sausage Shoppe
Summer is here! We are no longer shipping cheese due to the Hot Weather.
Shipping will resume in the Fall. When in Milwaukee, WI stop at one of our Stores to CarryOut
Thank you for your business order online in the fall.

5 Year Private Reserve Specialty Cheddar

Deer Creek  5 Year Private Reserve Specialty Cheddar

Click on Image to Enlarge

Item Number: 60-130
SKU 60-130
Weight: 0 Lb(s) 8 Oz
Please Call for Availability

Product Features

Awarded as Best U.S. Mature Cheddar at the International Cheese Awards for its superior taste

Gold Medal Winner – International Cheese Awards

As cheese ages, nuances in body, texture, and flavor develop and change over time. Deer Creek’s team of Wisconsin licensed cheese graders works closely to hand select vats that have retained the taste, texture, and quality of a highly revered Cheddar, even after five years of aging. Very few vats can make it to this level and retain their superiority. We are proud to certify that Deer Creek 5 Year Private Reserve remains a truly outstanding Wisconsin Grade A aged Cheddar.

Goes Well With:

  • Beers: Red Ales, Ambers
  • Wines: Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec, Syrah
  • Nibblies: Spanish Peanuts, Plain Almonds, Grapes, Peppercorn Crackers, Cured Meats


  • International Cheese Awards 2016 –Bronze: Best USA Cheddar, Extra Mature/Vintage
  • International Cheese Awards 2015 – Bronze
  • International Cheese Awards 2014 – Gold
  • American Cheese Society 2013 – 2nd